Contents:
Write a product review. Most helpful customer reviews on Amazon. Hobb Disappoints In This One. This trilogy is an anthem against misogyny, environmental destruction, colonial expansion, and body shaming. There is, of course, nothing wrong with that, even if those themes are a bit overdone nowadays. Many authors use their stories to press against injustice.
What Hobb seems to have forgotten is… well, the story. In comparison to her other works, this is just boring. The world-building is descriptive but unoriginal, and none of the characters shine in any meaningful way. In fact, Hobb completely fails to evoke in the reader compassion or empathy for any of the characters. Even the serially unfortunate protagonist seems to come by his misfortunes only through his own missteps and lack of foresight. She is one of my favorite authors. There are few greater works in this genre as her excellent Farseer and Fool series; however, this one feels like she was contractually obligated to produce something, and even she could not be bothered to care much about it.
This trilogy is my favorite of all Hobbs' many works and I'm not sure why. It's magic is more earthly, the settings and characters not glamorous dragons nor feuding courts nor Standing Stones.
I love all the other books; they have enriched my life and invaded my dreams. But this trilogy with its care for the earth, its recognition of the arrogance of men who try to rape the earth because they think they can, and a very unheroic-looking main character who matures into a very relevant low-key and altogether series of small endings. If you're interested in ecology or indigenous rights or three books of excellent prose, settle in.
No dragons, no princes, no Wolf Brothers, but an intricately crafted delight. Robin Hobb is my favorite author these days. She communicates with one when her father is almost killed and eaten. Sisarqua has turned into a dragon, naming herself Sintara, and is distraught to realize that her proportions are all wrong and she is not what she should be, and will likely never fly. Alise Kincarron is a plain, freckled young woman, past the prime age for marriage and suspecting spinsterhood.
Most of her time is consumed by her passion for dragons and her studies thereof. She is unsure of the attention she is getting from a handsome local Trader, Hest Finbok. When finally confronting him, he admits that he is not in love with her, but is wishing for a marriage of convenience for both of them. If she can provide him with an heir, he will fund her fancies, including her research of dragons, including a trip to study the hatchling dragons since he had caused her to miss a trip she had already planned to watch them hatch.
Agreeing, Alise begins to hope for a real marriage to her handsome suitor, but is desperately disappointed on her wedding night. She learns that the marriage was suggested by her childhood friend, Sedric. She ultimately decides that if she sold herself, she would demand a high price, and begins to use Hest's money freely to pursue her studies of dragons and Elderlings.
With some time having passed on the Tarman, the work with the wizardwood is finished. Captain Leftrin wants to give a lifetime contract to all of the workers to protect the secret of their illegal use of the forbidden substance. The only remaining man to sign is Swarge, who admits that he is betrothed and does not want to be separated from his new wife-to-be. Leftrin agrees to give a contract to Swarge's wife so that they may be together and Swarge signs the contract. Leftrin hopes that he will never hear from the man again.
Meanwhile, Alise has given up on all efforts to make Hest attracted, or even interested in her, as they have all been met with failure or worse. Hest is displeased with Alise's inability to produce an heir and comes for another one of his unpleasant attempts to impregnate her. When she is unwilling, he rapes her. After the shame of this event, she accuses him of being unfaithful to her, in the hopes of ending their marriage contract, and provides proof in certain things she has noted, such as his luxurious perfumes and a second house that he rents.
Hest is furious and demands that Sedric, his secretary and constant companion, confirm his fidelity. Sedric confirms, though it is later revealed to be a lie, as Sedric is, in fact, Hest's lover. Four years have passed since the hatching and Sintara is sad and tormented by the dragon memories that she is filled with. The dragons are weak and unable to feed themselves, relying on hunters to provide them with a limited amount of food. As the more feeble dragons die off, the stronger ones consume them to claim their ancestral memories. Tintaglia has gone missing, not having been seen for some time.
It is rumored that she has found a mate and no one, including the young dragons, believes that she will return. The dragons begin to yearn to find their way to the lost Elderling city of Kelsingra, or die trying. Mercor, who lacks in size what he makes up in wisdom, makes a plan to convince the Rain Wilds Council that it is their idea to transport the dragons toward the lost city using their ancestral memories as a guide. Alise confronts Hest about the promise he made on their marriage contract that she would be allowed to go on a trip to study the newly hatched dragons.
I think it's rather abrupt and very 'stop you in your tracks'. I just didn't see it heading that way, and I didn't think that it would be so sudden and wild. I think it worked as a shock factor and it was pretty bold and daring to end a book that way, it certainly makes me want to know what will happen next and I can't wait to move on with the story. Dragon Keeper is definitely a book for Robin Hobb fans, and fans only.
It's the first half of Book 1, technically, having been split for publishing reasons, so the story doesn't get underway for a long, long time. A lot of the text is spent building up characters and their motivations, so expect lots of exposition between dialogue. But who cares, it's Robin Hobb! We get right into the heads and mindset of being a dragon similar to being a cat The language, as always, is superb, and you will have never savoured a story more than this.
It's like a long walk in the woods, where you don't really have anywhere to be, and no responsibilities weighing on your mind. It doesn't all have to be court intrigue and power struggles like we're used to in the genre. Hobb gives you real characters on a much smaller scale, but the emotional payoff is none smaller for it. I read this with The Robin Hobb Collection book club —hop in the discussion with us! View all 12 comments. The Dragon Keeper is not epic. It doesn't wow me. This book should be read as an introduction to the books to come. Toward the end, things do heat up when all those newly introduced characters are thrown on a boat together which results in the first sneaky power games and head for a vaguely remembered magical city somewhere out th The Dragon Keeper is not epic.
Toward the end, things do heat up when all those newly introduced characters are thrown on a boat together which results in the first sneaky power games and head for a vaguely remembered magical city somewhere out there in the Rainwilds. I'm super confident that the books to come will be amazing.
And I'm excited to find out what Hobb has in store. However, several of what I consider those special, superb Hobb-ingredients are missing in The Dragon Keeper.
The Rain Wilds Chronicles: Dragon Keeper, Dragon Haven, City of Dragons, and The Liveship Traders Trilogy 3-Book Bundle: Ship of Magic, Mad Ship,. Editorial Reviews. From Publishers Weekly. Here be dragons—but debilitated, deformed, Back. Assassin's Quest (The Farseer Trilogy, Book 3) · Robin Hobb · out of 5 stars Kindle Edition. $ · Dragon Haven (Rain Wilds Chronicles, Vol.
Compelling characters for instance. For a big chunk of the book only Alise seems nicely fleshed out. And even she lacks the spunk of Althea and Malta, the two incredible heroines from The Liveship Traders. Greft a Draco Malfoy including servants and Sedric have potential. But captain Leftrin isn't exactly Brashen Trell material. His ability to impress me in the books to come will probably co-depend on whether he's capable of successfully corrupting Alise. My main concern however.. I miss that charming, evil bastard of a pirate Kennit! Or ANY Kennit-ish character. More importantly, Hobb always made a point of cleverly weaving multiple layers through her stories, some so hidden and secret, that as a reader I often sensed there was a delicious magical undercurrent to the story that was just..
In The Dragon Keeper , what you see is mostly what you get: Those intriguing Rainwild people are no longer a mystery, as they were when a veiled Reyn Khuprus offered Malta the most magical gifts. The dreamlike Elderlings with their buried cities lost a little of their appeal as well, now that it has become clear that humans can become them, when touched by dragons. Last but not least, is it crucial to read The Liveship Traders and The Farseer books before picking up this one?
The latter will definitely provide you with the complete picture and Hobb masterly connects her works, which often results in "oh my god, Amber is actually Paragon looks exactly like But the Farseer books are skippable. View all 29 comments. Jul 10, Shelby M. This story is intriguing! I was a little nervous because the Rain Wild Chronicles has mixed reviews. Feb 06, Mark Halse rated it really liked it Shelves: Though it pains me to give a Robin Hobb book anything less than 5 stars the ending to this book was an enormous middle finger.
This story was clearly chopped up by a publisher in hopes of making as much money as possible. The page count of each book alone is telling of this crime. Publishing politics aside, this book was Hobb business as usual and that means excellent character development. Robin Hobb writes stories that become a part of you and that's all a reader can ask.
Highly recommended if y Though it pains me to give a Robin Hobb book anything less than 5 stars the ending to this book was an enormous middle finger. Highly recommended if you have book two at the ready. Oct 30, Franco Santos rated it liked it Shelves: Some memories are best left undisturbed. Sometimes, if you forget something, it's because it's better forgotten. En The dragon keeper se presentan las bases para lo que va a suceder en los siguientes tomos de la saga, quiero creer.
A pesar de esto, es un buen libro, entretenido y para nada pesado. View all 3 comments. Review from Tenacious Reader: I also have to confess to reading the different series that make up The Realm of the Elderlings in the wrong order as I was ignorant of how much interconnection there is between all of them. That means I have read books both preceding and following this trilogy.
I really had no idea how much connected between them. But now I do, and even with my unique reading order, I am really enjoying this. Actually, I have to confess to enjoying knowing some of the connections that come from my knowledge of The Fitz and the Fool books, but I would have preferred to have read them in order and made the connections as they were presented. This book starts with the hatching of the cocoons created by the serpents at the end of The Liveship Traders.
These poor things were not given the proper start at life as they should have been. The journey they made to cocoon was far from ideal and took its price. And as a result, the hatched dragons are sorry things that dependent on humans and confined by their lack of flight. It is an interesting situation as dragons are born with memories of their ancestors, so they are very aware of the shortcomings and the life they are missing.
However, there are many secrets and adventures to be found here too and we follow a couple of new characters in this book who promise to discover to some pretty big events and secrets. View all 27 comments. I realize that sounds melodramatic, but technically it's accurate. I'm glad to revisit the fantasy world created by Robin Hobbone of the few true queens of fantasy not the fake onesagain and this journey takes us to the mysterious Rain Wild River and its forest, we travel upriver together with a bunch of Rain Wild misfits and a pack of deformed dragons in hope to discover the long-lost mystical city of dragons and the Elderlings. Reptile Licence is required for purchase. But the story was superb. The author takes her time with everything - I like dragons!
This is an area that we have seen bits of in Liveship Traders, but it was never focused on to the extent it is here. Thymara is a protagonist who is one of those that even by Rain Wilds standards is considered an outcast by her level of change.
I also really respected her desire to do more than her father expected of her, to look for something to do with her life. Alise is a character that I have had a bumpier ride with. She is the daughter of a Bingtown trader family, but hers is not a wealthy family, and she is not terribly attractive. As she passed prime marrying age without a single suitor, she has resigned to a life of spinsterhood, until suddenly she has, for some reason, caught the eye of Hest Finback, a wealty and very handsome Trader son.
Of course, as we all know, if something seems too good to be true, there is liable to be a reason. But even if she does, she may see the business logic in not being alone the rest of her life. She can be terribly practical. While she was anticipating spending her days alone as a spinster, she decided to take up an unusual hobby as a women, and pursue studying dragons and Elderlings. This is the part of her personality I like, her drive to do something other than just sit and embroider, and plan party and decorate.
Alise broke from the mold by pursuing her own interests, and I had to admire her for that trait. Books like this reinforce my decision to do a Backlist Burndown.
Dragon Keeper is the start of a journey that is making me binge read this series. I am glad I finally made time for this one! Jul 09, Helene Jeppesen rated it liked it. I was looking for a great fantasy story and that is exactly what I got. This book contains dragons, and even though this is clearly the beginning of a big journey and we don't get to spend that much time with the dragons, I can sense that Robin Hobb is going to rectify that in the next books in the series.
I liked how the dragons were portrayed as vulnerable as well as strong and fierce animals, because that made me grow to like them and care for them. We also get to follow the story from one of I was looking for a great fantasy story and that is exactly what I got. We also get to follow the story from one of the dragons' perspective which I thought was great.
Basically, this book is written in a lot of perspectives and I was a fan. I think Alise was my favourite character because she grows to be very independent, but there was not one character that I didn't like reading about. I was a bit confused, though, with the letters appearing between each chapter. They didn't add anything to the story for me, and I read through them quickly so that I could get on with the real story. All in all, I was quite a fan of this book and that's why I immediately ordered the sequel so that I can continue on with the journey.
As much as I love her writing, this was waaaaaaaaay too stretched out. It could have easily been half as it is now and would have been almost perfect. Further more, not much happened; it also ended like a chapter, not like a first part in a series. Still… the dragons ripped my heart in thousand pieces and some of their keepers too.
And I thought till now that Fitz was the unhappiest of her characters. As for the other characters, they are a lousy bunch. And all those meticulously endless detailed to the micron descriptions of them made it a tedious reading. However, with all these annoying facts, I liked it. I'm also hoping that things will improve with the advancing of the story.
No, not hoping, I know will improve. View all 16 comments. Jul 13, Jackie rated it it was amazing. Reading this book was like revisiting a favorite place. And now I am reading the manuscript for Dragon Haven, book 2 and it is even better. Fans of Liveship Traders. Full Review I tore through the first 9 books of Ms. Hobb's Ederlings world last year. This series wasn't complete however so I wasn't in a rush to start it. After almost a year away, it's good to be back. There is some overlap with the events of Tawny man, so I'd recommend you have read those as well as Liveship before tackling this one.
That said this book is slow. Any fan of Ms. Hobb will be used to this by now. She tends to meander at the start of her stories and takes her time before the main plot begins. This book might be the worst of the bunch. If that aspect of her writing bothers you, this series may not be for you.
I think in any other author I might give up in frustration, but for me Ms. Hobb's writing is such that I seem to enjoy myself even if very little action is taking place. I can't really put my finger on why either.
Maybe she's skilled me or something.. Things do finally get going however and we're introduced several new characters along the way that we know pretty well by the time they do. For fans of Liveship there are some appearances by old friends, who make me smile and cheer when they showed up however briefly. I think this is where Ms. I've rarely love or despise characters as much as I tend to with hers.
This series adds a few new ones that I may come to love, and certainly has several that I already can't stand. My only real complaint here is that the book sort of stops rather than ends. Just as things are really getting good too. I really just want to jump right into Dragon Haven , which thankfully I can do if I want to, but if I had to wait, or if you didn't want to read the whole series at once, could be annoying. Hobb's done a much better with ending her other early books in a series than this.
That said I'm eager to continue on and see where things go from here now that the stage has been set. View all 6 comments. Apr 23, Shelly K rated it it was amazing Shelves: If I did't already have Robin Hobb in my blood I may not have loved this book. As it is, I do and I did.
This is the continuation of the dragon's story that started in Live Ships. Tintaglia kind of irritates me. Turns out, it was great to return to the Rain Wilds. And there are some amazing new characters and relationships to get sucked in to. It's a bit of a slow star If I did't already have Robin Hobb in my blood I may not have loved this book. It's a bit of a slow start but there's just such a steady pace to Hobb's books that I didn't mind The dragons are much more interesting that I had expected.
They still have their serpent personalities that we saw in Live Ships, some are even recognizable. This book is clearly a beginning to a longer story. It stops abruptly and doesn't give you much choice but to keep reading on into the next instalment. I literally finished this book and started the next like it was a new chapter. I didn't plan on back to back reads but, like I said, there wasn't much choice.
Another bonus; the audio book has the same narrator as Live Ships making it that much more familiar. Apr 02, Mizuki rated it really liked it Shelves: I'm glad to revisit the fantasy world created by Robin Hobbone of the few true queens of fantasy not the fake onesagain and this journey takes us to the mysterious Rain Wild River and its forest, we travel upriver together with a bunch of Rain Wild misfits and a pack of deformed dragons in hope to discover the long-lost mystical city of dragons and the Elderlings.